Very oversized but so cute for the winter!

Great for cold weather. Could dress up or down.

I thought about purchasing this and still might, but I do feel like this kind of sweater can get really pilly. I could wear xs or small these days and I went with small and glad I did.

Fun oversized knit sweater. Super warm and heavy weight, perfect for layering or wearing by itself.

This is the absolute most comfortable sweater ever. It’s heavy so keeps you warm on really cold days. Definitely oversized and boxy but I loved it.

Soft, warm and cozy for fall. Long without being too big - great with leggings!

High quality, gorgeous cream sweater- perfect for fall!

The oversized fisherman’s sweater of my dreams

Love it!

So easy to wear with everything and heavy enough that it feels super high quality.

Good oversized fit

Surprised at how soft and great with jeans. Warm and practical. Happy to discover success renting madewell not just for jeans.

I have a few “forever” pieces on my list that I’m in no hurry to purchase since they’re not trendy and I want to find ones that I will wear in 10 years and feel just as good in, as I did when I bought them. This sweater completes my “classic cable-knit” on the checklist. I envisioned it giving 90’s Diane Keaton or Meg Ryan…something to pair with any type of bottom that goes in and out of style but the sweater that doesn’t. My favorite part about this sweater is the oversized fit and how long the sleeves are (I have long arms) and yet how it falls so feminine and pretty. It’s not hot…went for a walk and felt the cold air come through which I love. Was worth leaving a long review because I BOUGHT IT THE MINUTE AFTER I PUT IT ON. When you just know you’ve found that capsule piece, you know!

I’m wearing an xs in the photos. It looks fine but the shoulders are so weird. Like the sleeves are tight but the armpit hits like below my boobs lol

Very bulky and oversized. It added too much bulk for me and I never wore it.

Wayyyy too big- but wasn't renting for anything other than everyday wear...

This is my first box so I wasn’t sure how to pick items. This sweater is fine. It’s a bit boxy and very warm. Nice, thick material.

Rented before and loved it. Didn't wear it as many times this trip. It was a little longer than I remembered. Overall would rent again.

I wore this more times than I care to admit. It was cozy and the perfect length.

Wore it to work and to run errands. Very comfortable

It's a really cute sweater but wow is it oversized! I sized down one size and it was still fairly large. The sweater is very warm though.

I wore this in Iceland and was pleasantly surprised how warm it was! Plus my 22-year-old daughter said it was super cute. Score!

Very cozy; wore with leggings

Big fit but cute with jeans. Warm

I loved this sweater! It was so soft and perfect with jeans or leggings. I sized up to and XL for the very oversized look, which was fantastic!

This sweater is a great staple to your fall wardrobe. Paired it with both jeans and boots and casual pants and mules and was perfect. Nice knit, its a warm sweater.

Nice and long, oversized to wear with leggings. So comfy. Only a tiny bit itchy near the neck, but only if it started getting too warm. Definitely for cold weather.

Fits comfortably oversized and is so soft and cozy. I am tempted to just buy this one!

cute oversized sweater, just very big and heavy if thats what you're going for (winter/ layering) looks it works

As advertized. Loved it.

This sweater was oversized and super comfy. I wore it like every day!

You can never go wrong with a classic fisherman ivory sweater

This was a thicker chunkier sweater but I paired it with cozy suede leggings for an easy comfortable outfit!

Very comfy for cold weather, warm sweater, runs a bit large

A very comfortable sweater, not too itchy

super cute and trendy sweater. looks great tucked with jeans

I should have sized down bc it was too big but I still wore it and loved it!