With shorts, mom jeans, denim skirt - this shirt pairs well with everything. It has a stiffness to it which I loved, but wasn’t expecting. True to size.

Super cute top. This could be worn dressed up to work or casually. It's a thicker knit/ sweater material. Would definitely rent again.

Fits well and runs how it should. Great in hot weather too!

Cropped but fine with high waisted skirt.

Super cute date night too for the summer! Europe summer vibes ✨

Size up if you are a 34 C

I loved this cardigan tank! In my opinion, it runs true to size and has quite a bit of stretch. I recommend renting your normal size, although the arm holes were a little big. This style is roomy throughout and is not super fitted. It is more boxy but flattering. I wore this with the Levi's High Baggy Short and loved the combo!

This top is so perfect for every occasion from day to day to brunch or on vacation. It fit true to size with a little stretch. I wore it with jeans but would’ve been super cute with linen or white pants.

Loved that this has versatility by wearing with a long sleeve underneath or not. A bit tight but still fit.

This was a good top but not a ton of stretch (if any) and was HOT. I wore in Europe in Sept and there was no breathe ability. Otherwise, very cute.

I’m a normal size S/DD-chest but sized up to an XL based on the reviews. As an open vest over a shirt? I adore. As a standalone button-up? It’s a little wonky. While it’s the appropriate fit, the armholes gape just a tad and the buttons lay in a way that make it look like it’s too-tight across the chest even with the extra room. All in all, I wouldn’t have sized down; XL was the right choice.

I loved everything about this shirt… except how it fit in the chest. I had to keep adjusting it otherwise it looked weird with the line too high. Would probably fit better on small chested ladies.

I don't know why I think Madewell is going to impress me when it always disappoints. Top ran small and buttons gaped bc of my boobs. Made it work for the night but if you have any kind of chest, you probably should go up 2 sizes

Odd fabric, fits ok, cuts close to the underarm.

I probably should’ve listened to the reviews. I didn’t think this one was very flattering. It was fine for dinner out but nothing I’d jump at renting again.

I’m a big Madewell fan but this one didn’t really do it for me. It was a little too small

This top is very cute but runs small. I expected the fabric to have more stretch but found it to be quite fitted with very little give. There is darting in the bust area too, so if you have a larger chest like myself I would size up 1-2 sizes. This would make for a great work outfit if paired with a blazer or for a vacation since it is lightweight and versatile.

Easy to wear with jeans, skirts or slacks

I had ordered the medium and it fit small. This one is the large and it fit me well.

I took the advice of the comment section and sized up to the XXL and it fit perfectly! So cute with jeans or navy pants!

Love love loved this top. It was borderline too small for a larger chest but I made it work and almost bought!

definitely need high-rise shorts or jeans with it it's a little short but adorable I wore an extra small

It’s fitted and well constructed. It had functional buttons .

Was cute but too small.

A little short but worked well with mid-rise jeans. I liked it with the top

Cute fit

Loved this one, almost bought it! Super easy to pair with things and fit nice, but probably would be a bit tight if you have a larger chest.

Runs a little small in my opinion but fits me fine and I’ve worn it both everyday and to a networking event. Perfect basic piece!

I received compliments on this item. It is a bit on the short side in the length for me.

Stylish but classic at the same time

Nice material, thick and stretchy. I am usually an XS at Madewell and I have a pretty small chest, but this is pulling a little bit between the buttons on me. Otherwise, great for everyday. Thought it might be ok with a sweater for work but it is too cropped.

I loved this shirt!

I should have sized up a little. But it was a fun shirt!